2013 Oxford Union Debate on Innovation and Stagnation
23:47 “And so if you say that progress has been driven by technology in the advanced nations of the world, in the west, this seems to me to be the strongest prima facie case one could make, that something has changed in a very radical way. Mark’s talk here was an incredible sort of blast from the past.” Share
Garry Kasparov, Peter Thiel, Mark Shuttleworth and Kenneth Rogoff debate whether weak growth reflects technological stagnation and a more risk-averse society. Thiel contrasts wage and energy trends with progress in computing, while Rogoff attributes the downturn chiefly to a credit-driven financial crisis. The exchange turns to public research, oil, air travel, debt, inflation and the uneven distribution of global growth.
Passages
26:15 “Credit and technology both make claims on the future. And a credit crisis happens when the future is not as good as expected.” Share
27:01 “And there has been this very strange phenomenon which, where we’ve had one bubble after another after another after another. Japan in the 80s, tech in the 90s, housing, finance, all sorts of other things in the last decade, and I believe now probably a government bubble.” Share
Search what Thiel said from Claude, ChatGPT or your own code. See plans