Joel Greenblatt on the Magic Formula, 2006
Joel Greenblatt presents his Columbia value-investing framework, the Magic Formula, which ranks companies by return on capital and earnings yield. He reviews backtests and challenges around bias, risk and periods of underperformance, then contrasts the screen with Gotham Capital’s concentrated approach using normalized earnings. Audience questions cover holding periods, shorting, macroeconomics, projections, special situations and Foot Locker.
Passages
6:22 “And what we did was we defined good companies and we defined good company as companies that could earn a high return on capital. Okay.” Share
18:46 “The way I looked at it is, and the way I described in the book is these are above average companies you’re buying at below average prices. Gee, that makes sense.” Share
27:13 “I say if you do good work and you can value a company well, in other words, and your analysis is correct, the market will usually agree with you. But sometimes it can take two or three years.” Share
36:21 “The difference between what we do at Gotham and what this simple back test was is that we do not use last year’s earnings. What we use is normalized earnings three or four years out.” Share
52:49 “And the other thing about companies that earn a high return on capital is that they’re more likely to have some kind of barrier to entry. Because most businesses that have been around for a while, if they don’t have barriers to entry, earn average returns on capital so bad businesses never earn a high return on capital bad.” Share
Search what Greenblatt said from Claude, ChatGPT or your own code. See plans